Show summary Hide summary
Jan Suraaj founder Prashant Kishor on Thursday accused the Delhi Police of detaining protesters at the direction of Union Home Minister Amit Shah, and urged voters in Bihar to use the ballot box, not demonstrations alone, to remove the ruling coalition in the state. With the upcoming MLC elections looming, Kishor framed the events as a test of whether citizens will hold those in power to account.
Kishor spoke at an event in Saharsa, linking recent police actions and public safety lapses to broader governance failures. He argued that relying on street demonstrations will not prevent future reprisals unless electoral majorities change the balance of power.
Accusations over policing and political interference
Guru Tegh Bahadur remembered 2026: sacrifice that preserved religious freedom
Bangladeshi Hindus face 85 attacks in 66 days: rights expert warns of escalating violence
Pointing to the detentions of protesters, Kishor said law enforcement appeared to be acting on political orders rather than independent judgement. He referenced recent comments by the Union home minister that questioned the effectiveness of protests, using that line of argument to press his central point: elections are the mechanism to check state authority.
He warned that if voters do not respond at the polls, similar interventions by police could become more commonplace for others who dissent.
Crime, encounters and accountability
At the same gathering, Kishor criticised the Bihar government’s record on law and order after two recent high-profile killings — a retired customs officer in Bhojpur and a police constable in Nalanda. He said these cases underscore a breakdown in routine policing, not the rare heroics often publicised by authorities.
Kishor argued that attention appears skewed toward dismantling organised syndicates tied to liquor and sand rather than strengthening basics of policing and investigation. He also took aim at the growing reliance on police encounters as a public-safety solution, saying such actions are the province of the courts to adjudicate and that extra-judicial measures risk inflaming social tensions if they are perceived to be driven by caste or religious motives.
The immediate consequence, Kishor said, is erosion of trust in institutions that are meant to protect citizens equally.
On the Vaishali boat tragedy — in which 13 children died after a boat capsized in the Ganga — he questioned reports that rescue teams were not available, arguing that the episode exposed priorities misplaced by both policymakers and voters when safety is judged through the lens of identity politics rather than public welfare.
- Stronger local policing: Kishor called for professional, accountable police services focused on crime prevention and investigation.
- Judicial oversight: He urged that alleged extra-judicial killings be examined by the courts and independent bodies, not celebrated as shortcuts to justice.
- Emergency preparedness: The Vaishali incident, he said, highlights the need for functional rescue teams and disaster planning.
- Electoral response: Kishor urged voters to treat the MLC elections as the practical route to change, rather than relying on protests.
What this means for voters: Kishor framed the coming polls as a referendum on governance and public safety. If his critique resonates, parties seen as responsible for the lapses — he named the BJP, JD(U) and the broader NDA alliance — may face political consequences in the MLC contests. He stopped short of outlining a specific electoral strategy, focusing instead on the link between administrative accountability and daily security for citizens.
Officials from the state or the Union Home Ministry have not, as of his remarks, issued a detailed rebuttal. The unfolding political and legal responses will determine whether the debate shifts from protest and accusation to institutional reform.
Kishor closed by urging concrete correction of systemic failures rather than rhetorical defences after tragedies, saying that improved policing, transparent investigations and preparedness are prerequisites for restoring public confidence.
