(CHAKRA) To The People of India, Greetings, I address you collectively as a nation, as nation builders, and as individuals capable of rationale and reasoning.
As human beings we are endowed with an enhanced intellectual faculty, which is really the only thing that confers us a distinct position in the animal kingdom. Genetically, we are 99% similar to chimps, but that 1% sets us apart. This difference manifests itself in a very special place- the human mind.
Our choices define us, and it is the mind where all choices are made. In the mind alone, transformations that shape the external world are first conceived before being put into action. Indeed, it is a powerful tool, but with great power comes great responsibility. Unfortunately, we have been shirking our responsibilities for a long time now.
Today, we live in an age of social crisis. The trouble isn’t lack of intelligence or some debility; rather it is the lack of knowledge, and the subsequent inaction on our part that follows. Without knowledge, we cannot make informed decisions- crucial decisions that shape our future, and that of our nation.
A region having seismic fault-lines is most prone to geological disturbances- more commonly known as earthquakes. India too is replete with its own fault-lines, but on the political, educational, cultural, social, economic and intellectual fronts. These fault lines disintegrate the country from within, making it susceptible to exploitation in one form or another. I cannot possibly address all of the issues here- that would require a voluminous tome, not an essay. I will however give a bird’s eye view of it, touching upon the general ideas, providing the impetus to do your own subsequent research where required.
Time and time again we hear about “India rising”; sweeping remarks about its financial success, or last year’s GDP growth, at par with- at times even overtaking- China. In short, we hear only about the things that make us feel good as a nation, seldom do you hear about what goes about behind the scenes; the foreign and domestic forces at hand in demolishing the national structure, one day at a time, one unit at a time. These keenly neglected newsreels are precisely what we will present here, but first a brief history lesson.
LOOKING BACK IN TIME:
The Hindu/Indian culture was the cradle of advanced civilization. Everything flourished in this ancient land- Philosophy, Mathematics, Science, Literature, Commerce, Arts, Yoga, Ayurveda, Architecture, Governance, Logic, Astrology, Astronomy, Medicine- you name it, we had it. We even came up with the same postulates of Pythagorus’ theorem before he did, presented in Vedic scriptures, detailing the size and shapes of yajna altars. Thus the cornerstone of every great thought found its epicenter in India.
Being a highly evolved and peace-loving culture, we knew the value of our values. We gave birth to some of the most profound luminaries that walked this earth:- Vyasa, Vashishta, Adi Shankaracharya, Mahavira, Buddha, Valmiki, to name a few, and an endless, unbroken lineage of enlightened Acharyas in this Guru-Shishya Parampara (student-teacher tradition). Then things went awry.
When the Islamic invaders attacked India, there was large scale cultural dishevelment. Wealth was plundered, women were defiled, ancient religions were displaced, and scores of temples were demolished. It would be fitting to term the Mughals- perhaps with the exception of Akbar- as less of rulers and more of barbarians. Long lapses of time make us routinely forget that first it was Babar, who destroyed the Ram Mandir at Ayodhya, creating an long-standing legacy of temple destruction throughout erstwhile India, which ended only with the demise of the last Mughul ruler, the ruthless Aurangzeb. Thus India underwent a painful transformation from being the most prolific producers and inventors, to passive ones, because we had to direct our minds and resources toward resisting the onslaught.
The next blow came from the Europeans, when they landed ashore under the pretext of trade. We did not them for an extended stay-back to sample more of our curry dishes- they invaded us. Already weakened by the Mughuls, and thus falling technologically behind, we did not put up much of a challenge to the British, and were once again at the mercy of another foreign power.
It is a well recognized fact that India was the world’s economic superpower for the most part of recorded history. However, due to the Islamic and British invasions, contrasted by the Industrial revolution hitting Europe, India fell behind in the GDP race in the early 19th century, and we never again regained our lost position again
It is crucial to note that in spite of our numerous successes, Indians never set out to conquer other nations, we have always been self sustaining and self satisfied. Even with the outsiders who ruled us, we tried to form amicable relationships, allowing them to assimilate into our way of living, despite their best attempts to extricate us from our own. It is in our cultural DNA to always be accommodating, and therein lies the greatness of our Hindu/Indian culture.
The Hindu-Jewish Summit was held in New Delhi, in 2010. The Jewish Rabbis graciously admitted that the Hindus alone gave them shelter when they were chased into exile by everyone else. Whether it was being ousted from their homeland by the Muslims in Arabia, the anti-Semitist movements of the Christians, or facing the holocaust at the hands of the Nazi regime; Jews have faced a long history of persecution. It is in India where they found their long awaited peace.
The same applied for Parsis- the Zoroastrians now integrated in India. Like the Jews, they too were harassed away from their native Persia by the Arabic Muslims, and thus made their way into the Hindu/Indian culture upon their arrival at Gujarat, into which they were peacefully assimilated.
A NEED FOR INTEGRATION OF CULTURES:
Today, India is a potpourri of many world religions, but it is fast losing its culture due to many eroding factors which we will explore. As we made abundantly clear above, historically, it is the Hindu/Indigenous culture alone that has allowed for the peaceful integration of people in our nation. The cultures associated with the major western religions- with all due respect- do not allow for this plurality in India, as they wish for others to do and believe in the same things that they do.
A sparkling example of this is Dr.Zakir Naik. If you have seen him on television or ‘Youtube’, you would know exactly what I mean. For those who haven’t, he is Islam’s answer to Televangelists, performing his theatrical antics on stage believing that the public is comprised of incompetents. Unfortunately that is true, as most of his audience consist of yes-men. The same applies to Christian Missionaries in India, whose primary motive for the most part is to convert the nation to their faith. That will be further discussed as we proceed.
Pre-Independence, Hindus and Muslims co-existed side-by-side in relative peace, until the seeds of divisiveness had been planted into the Indian soil by the colonizers. Almost all Muslims living in India are converts, and culturally are still very much Indian, but today they are being led astray with the solid influence of figures living in the Arab world, and their dialectics are contrary; even antagonistic to the Indian culture. Over time, those figures are transforming the psyche of Indian Muslims to that of the Arabic world. This breaks the nation from within.
Similarly, the Christian Missionaries who “work” in India are trying to mould India from a very Western angle and that has been causing a lot of friction in rural villages, which is responsible for scores of families falling apart.
In India, family has been the most important social unit, and these domestically implanted “push factors” coupled with foreign influenced “pull factors” are causing massive damage to the social structure of India.
The Hindu religion on the other hand does not require its followers to convert anybody; it prescribes a way of living for the adherents alone, and for no one else. We neither wish to be converted nor are we looking to convert, which is what makes the associated Hindu/Indian culture the most pluralistic and accommodating of all.
As a Hindu, one has no personal restrictions against entering a Church or a Mosque, just as freely as he worships in his own temple, but today it is some fundamentalist sitting in the Middle-East, who determines what Indian Muslims should and should not do.
Let me be very clear here. Adopting a Hindu culture does not mean one needs to adopt the Hindu religion, one can practice their own faith, just as the Jews, Parsis, Jains, Buddhists, Sikhs and the Vedic followers have merged seamlessly into a unified Hindu/Indian culture, and quite successfully too. This alone can save our country from internal fragmenting.
Our Ex- President Dr.APJ Abdul Kalam serves as a perfect example of this. There is no doubt in anyone’s mind that he has been one of the greatest modern contributors to our national structure, and in his capacity has done more for the nation than credited for. His interest at heart has always been India, and despite being born in a Muslim family, he has shown no hesitation in appreciating his Indian roots.
When in Rome, do as the Romans do, it only makes perfect sense that those living in India follow the same principle, without having to give up their religious beliefs and practices. Thus we see that adopting an indigenous culture alone can stop the country from the internal fragmentation envisioned by divisive forces.
In this kind of unity alone lies strength. No one loses their identity; they simply become part of a greater Indian story.
UNDERSTANDING PSEUDO-SECULARISM:
When an organization or entity, in their pretentious bid to be overly secular, behaves in a totally un-secular fashion, this behaviour is termed as ‘Pseudo-Secularism’. When such pseudo-secularism is put into practice, the ones who primarily suffer are the majority inhabitants of the country; in our case, Hindus.
A functioning democracy should reflect the interest of the people, providing equal rights to all and sundry. As we will discover, the major institutions in our country such as the government, media and educational system are severely crippling the nation through their non-secular practices. Let’s take them on one by one.
PSEUDO-SECULARISM IN THE GOVERNMENT:
Sonia Gandhi, born in Italy, under the name Edvige Antonia Albina Maino, and the rest of the Congress Party have time and again proven that their governance is detrimental to the development of our nation.
It is entirely frightening that in a country of nearly 1.2 billion people, most are oblivious to the facts surrounding the people they elect to power.
Dr. Subramaniam Swamy has collected plenty of incriminating evidence against the Congress officials on many counts, yet the proceedings are moving at a snail’s pace. It would appear that some are in fervent hope of outliving the prosecutor. The media too has unnecessarily been giving him a hard time, despite his efforts to expose corrupt individuals in power. The supporting evidences for Dr. Swamy’s claims are up for display on his website. You may draw your own conclusions from the same.
I can understand that we didn’t really have that much of a choice thwarting the British; what’s done is done, but honestly, must we make the same mistake with the Italian born as well? We need to wean off this colonized mentality and learn to elect one of our own; someone who understands the nation better, someone who is interested in its well being, and someone who can effectively govern it.
Trivia: The family name, ‘Gandhi’, has merely been adopted to play to the sentiments of the masses; sadly it worked. The lesser said about Mrs. Gandhi’s not-so- illustrious child, Rahul Gandhi, the better. One may also want to do some inquiry into what his real name is, as the family has a long history of adopting names that resonate well with the public.
Dressed in white, smiling and waving at the camera does not qualify one to run a nation of 120 crore people, competence does. On all counts, the Gandhi scion is unfit to bear this impending responsibility. It would be a shame to see him as our next Prime Minister in the 2014 General Elections.
MINORITY APPEASEMENT:
Now, the Congress Government partakes in an activity called ‘Minority Appeasement’, which you may consider one of the package deals under the provisions of Pseudo-Secularism.
Here is how and why it works to their advantage, and this will directly tie in to the need for Hindus to be more organized socio-culturally and politically.
In the process of Minority Appeasement, the Government will be extra nice to the Muslim and Christian populace, but they will conveniently ignore other minorities such as Sikhs, Jews, Jains etc. The reason is very simple. Muslims and Christians in India are highly organized in their joint decision making strategies. There is a very high level of agreement amongst them; hence if you can win the confidence of a few, you win them all. That is why an overwhelming majority of Muslims and Christians will vote for Congress alone, which is the reason they are appeased in the first place.
In the case of Hindus, our votes are divided. We cannot reach consensus even over regional MLAs- let alone electing a National Government. This is the reason why the Government must stoop to the level of Minority Appeasement, because the minorities are highly homogenized in their collective decisions. They have no reason to be nice to Hindus; hence the Hindus lie at the suffering end. This absolute lack of socio-political unity among Hindus is the main cause for anti-Hindu parties running the country.
Even Church and Mosque funds are mainly handled by their respective autonomous religious institutions, but when it comes to Temple funds, for some reason the Government often wants to interfere and take control.
Year 2011 presented a shameful incident regarding the Sri Padmanabhaswamy Temple. It is a matter of pride that the members of the Travancore Royal Family were the caretakers of an estimated US$26.76 billion; not having used it for themselves, and a matter of shame that the State Government wished to manage this fund.
For a very long time, Indian Muslims were being provided a Haj subsidy by the government to go to Mecca. In 2007 the government spent Rs. 47,454 per passenger. In December, 2011, Christians were accorded a subsidy to pilgrimage to Jerusalem. It was only after much struggle that the Tamil Nadu Government extended the same rights to Hindus to visit Mansarovar.
United we stand, divided we fall. As Hindus, our lack of consensus on issues is one of the primary reasons for our downfall as a nation.
I once read a joke on the internet: “The second stupidest thing America did was elect Bush as President, but the stupidest thing they did was elect him again.” I sincerely hope our nation does not make the same mistake with the present Government, because if it does, we cannot blame anyone but ourselves. As the saying goes, “fool me once; shame on you, fool me twice; shame on me”.
PSEUDO-SECULARISM IN THE EDUCATIONAL SYSTEM:
Educational centers are the most important places to begin shaping our understanding of the world. What we learn in school and college is often what we develop a life-long affinity for.
When you infect the educational system, you are infecting minds; not one, but many. It spreads like an epidemic. Horizontally; it grows by infecting the contemporary population, and vertically; through the generations of culturally deprived children.
It should not come across as much of a surprise, that a large portion of our school and college syllabus is patterned after Western thought, but before I get into that I’d like to point out a fundamental flaw in the modern Indian Education System.
In ancient times, there was equal emphasis on the sciences as well as cultural ethos. Sanskrit Literature abounds with rigorous treatises on logic which would make the Greek philosophers look juvenile in comparison. For sampling purposes, please study one of our Nyaya Shastras. On the other hand, our texts also painted a gentler, more picturesque view of life. The ancients understood the importance of striking this balance and with good reason too.
The brain is divided into hemispheres; the left and the right. The right side is concerned with aesthetics, languages, emotions, intuition, empathy, self image, inter-personal relationships, and a holistic appreciation of things. The left side deals with logic, analysis, objectivity, goals, and is detail oriented. Too much of right with very little left would leave behind a sentimental wreck; irrational and lacking objectivity. Too much of left with little right would give rise to an automaton; a flesh and blood robot with no sentiments or appreciation of the finer side of life. Neither one of these individuals is socially fit.
A well developed person is adequately developed in both hemispheres. He caters to both his emotional and analytical needs as and when required. Unfortunately, our educational system is primarily focused only on the left, turning children into mechanical zombies before every exam, giving no chance to develop their creative side. Parents and teachers need to address this problem. The formative years of children are their school going years, and will vastly determine their future personality.
As the decades pass, we are giving lesser importance to value education and appreciation of Indian culture. The Board of Education needs to recognize this problem, and focus on finding a way to incorporate cultural activities into their education.
Introducing Indian dance forms such as Bharat Natyam, Oddisi, Kuchchipudi, Kathak etc- depending on the State you hail from; Yoga, for a sound mind and body as part of Physical Education, and Carnatic and Hindustani Sangeet, are good steps to take.
These need to find their way into the lives of children. If you are a parent concerned about negative influences on your little ones, try enrolling them into these Indo-cultural activities and mark the difference for yourselves. Even if the schools do not offer them, find a nearby cultural center for Indian arts; every major city in India has at least a few.
Small efforts on your part will turn them into well rounded children, and that can only happen if they are familiar with their cultural ethos.
PRESERVATION OF SANSKRIT:
For several reasons, attempts to bury Sanskrit as a language have been made. One of the primary reasons being that the majority of Hindu literature and scriptures have been written in Sanskrit, so when the language dies, automatically there are fewer people taking interest in these ancient works, so the associated religion and culture start dying along with it, leaving plenty of room for those with ulterior motives to take advantage of this situation.
If there exists an option between Sanskrit and a foreign language offered in school, opt for Sanskrit. It is only the pseudo-secular mentality in our heads that we feel something “foreign” is better, or “cooler”- well it isn’t, nor is it going to impress anyone. It is simply an idea that has been fed to us for a very long time, which we have digested quite successfully.
The good news is that Sanskrit is not a dead language yet. The bad news is it will be if you allow it to happen. Please don’t. We should be just as proud of it as we are of English. It is an important part of your heritage, and its preservation lies in your hands.
MARXIST CURRICULUM:
Every country having a rich and varied heritage would be proud of it. It is disparaging that in spite of living in the land of the Ramayana and Mahabharata; two of the lengthiest and culturally meaningful historical epics, they do not find their way into the school curriculum despite having some very good English translations, yet we find mention of Shakespeare, Gilgamesh and Rumi. Furthermore, we learn tales from Aesop’s Fables, for “Value Education”, but not beautiful ones from the Puranas or Panchatantra.
To illustrate, there is a story in the Puranas, where Ganesha and his brother Karthikeya decide to have a race to see who can go around the world the quickest. Karthikeya sets off like a bolt of lightning, while Ganesha slowly encircles his parents- Lord Shiva and Mother Parvati- 3 times before Karthikeya returns. Ganesha states that his parents mean the world to him, and is declared the winner.
This is what India is about; there is so much to learn from these little stories. It is painfully evident that however good things are, Pseudo-Secularism will always undermine the greatness of our culture.
Dance and music in India have always been hinged on devotion to the Lord, one cannot separate the means from the end, yet we find just that happening. In Kalakshetra, a renowned fine arts school in India, most Ganesha images on which (as per tradition) pooja would be performed, were removed in an attempt to be a more secular.
It gets even worse at University level; pointedly in the case of Liberal Arts majors. Now their entire syllabus not only ignores Hindu Literature, but is often antagonistic to it. Once again, it is very becoming of them to read philosophies of Plato, Aristotle, Socrates, Marx, Descartes and other Westerners, but not any Indian school of philosophical thought such as Vedanta, Tarka, Nyaya, Sankhya, Vaisheshika and etc. If they do happen to read ancient Indian texts, many do so only with a critical eye, not with the reverence that they were intended for, and how can they, when their schools did not provide them any appreciation of these texts via culture based value education? So they end up writing acidic papers on the Hindu culture in the light of their warped understanding of contexts and perspectives.
In summary, you have little kids that have grown up, all ready to be sent off to college, still traditionally impoverished in their thought process. Then due to their inadequate supplementary education, they set themselves up for more more-of-the-same, and get sucked right into the game of rebelling against their own culture, scoring self goal after another. It is truly a no-win situation for them.
These sadly misplaced students find their way into popular media by becoming Journalists, News Reporters, Authors, Historians, Social workers or Western styled Lobbyists. Several of them take up teaching positions, and they teach their students the same things that they had been taught. Thus the vicious circle completes itself, with another generation getting ready for the same treatment. It should be noted that there are still a few exceptional people that I appreciate in each of these disciplines cited above, who do have their understanding in right place; however the general trend is still downhill.
PSEUDO-SECULARISM IN THE MEDIA:
As mentioned, some of the graduating batches of pseudo-secular individuals are likely to pick careers in media/broadcasting, and here is where they wreak wide-spread havoc.
Already steeped in Marxist thought, having only a perfunctory academic knowledge of Indian tradition, and completely removed from our cultural ethos, these media men and women think they understand what is good for India better than many Indians who have fortunately not undergone such a cultural alienation as them.
So far we uncovered the mechanism at work, but who is pushing the buttons? As a common civilian lacking access to inside information, I will refrain from making any statements I cannot fully substantiate, so as an exercise, I do encourage typing the phrase ‘Who Owns the Indian Media’, and performing an internet search on it, from which you can draw your own conclusions.
It isn’t surprising that the vocabulary of some media personalities is replete with mocking adjectives for Hindus taking up some prominent public position; be it a Swami or a Politician. In other words, it is okay if you are a devout Christian or a Muslim, and taking part in politics, but if you are a Hindu, you are automatically associated with one or more of the following terms: “God-men”, “saffron brigade”, “fundamentalist”, “Right-winged terrorist”, “communal’ and more.
There are deviants found everywhere, but for every scandal one can associate a Hindu figure with, ten or more scandals could be pointed out connected to the Church. Would the Indian Media dare extend the same disrespect to Christian Clerics or Muslim Imams, as they do towards Swamis? Not by a long shot.
Another favorite pass-time of the Media is R.S.S. (Rashtriya Swayamsevak Sangh) bashing. We have all heard it on television and read it in the papers; the media spends more time dogging after R.S.S. than it does chastising real terrorist organizations.
However not everyone is that biased, here is what a former SC Judge, K.T. Thomas, has to say:
“There is a smear campaign that RSS was responsible for Gandhi’s assassination just because the assassin was once an RSS worker,” he said, adding that the organisation had been “completely exonerated” by the court. “This smear campaign must end against RSS,” he said.
“I am a Christian. I was born as a Christian and practise that religion. I am a church-going Christian. But I have also learnt many things about RSS,” he said.
“During the Emergency, RSS was the only non-political organisation which fought against it, he said. “We owe very much to RSS for sacrificing many lives for regaining our fundamental rights,” said Thomas.
That should put the matter at rest. Plenty more could be said about the media, but this gives the general idea.
Read PART 2: Open Letter to India: A Call to Action
By Prashant Parikh
Ramesh says
January 3, 2012 at 2:35 amAn excellent article. Kudos to the author. You should really consider writing a small book on this subject.
Iragavarapu Narasimhacharya says
January 3, 2012 at 3:12 amCongrats for awakening India from its doldrums.
Neha Agrawal says
January 3, 2012 at 5:45 pmExcellent work…
Ram says
January 3, 2012 at 11:36 pmThank you Ramesh ji, Narasimhacharya ji, Neha 🙂 The battle is far from over, now if only the public opens its eyes
Anjani says
January 4, 2012 at 3:09 amHi Prashant ,
You did a wonderful job. Words are not enough to express my appreciation for your hard working. This should become a non -detailed kind of book to the school children to know about our country. Parents should encourage their children to take Sanskrit language as second language and learn Indian art to understand our values and culture .
atul says
January 4, 2012 at 8:27 amSuperb Prashant ! Well researched , concise and brilliantly written .
Avadhesh Gupta says
January 4, 2012 at 11:12 amMind blowing Sir !…Keep contributing such wonderful articles equipped with wonderful facts about Hinduism and pseudo secularism in India …We need you infact in such a time of transition when Bharat is moving towards a dangerous phase gradually ..we need to be awakened any how …
Jai Hind
Sunil Mumbai says
January 4, 2012 at 3:37 pmDear Prashant,
Is it hypocrizy to leave India to study in United State? Is it a fact that your article is peppered with factual errors? Please do your homework. I am a true bleu Mumbai boy. Is it a fact that Indira Nehru married a Zoroastrian , Feroze Gandhi? Why would Indira Gandhi call her sons? Rajiv Nehru and Sanjay Nehru? Are we all debating on English? How about Sanskrit? What you do for India? Nothing. Why don’t you enter a Naxal area? Do you have courage? I doubt.
Rohit Salecha says
January 4, 2012 at 4:49 pmVery good contrasting picture of Our Glorious History and our gloomy present. The sad part is , many of us are still oblivious of our gloomy present and ignorant about our history.
Ram says
January 5, 2012 at 8:22 amThank you Anjani ji, Atul ji, Avadhesh ji and my old friend, Rohit, your kind words encourage me to push myself further and strive harder to be of service. I would truly like what I’ve said to be a simple disclaimer. NamashkArams to all of you
Sunil Mumbai (is this your last name?),
There is absolutely no hypocrisy in studying in any part of the world. Leaving political boundaries is not the same as forgetting where one is from. Thank you for asking me to do my homework, I have, however I cannot make the same recommendation to you as for that you would first need to go to school. Naming her sons ‘Rajiv’ and ‘Sanjay’ was nothing more than earning the trust of the majority Hindu nation. The same reason why the name ‘Khan’ was switched to ‘Gandhi’.
You may want to glance at this long and hard before throwing further accusations. http://alchemystical.files.wordpress.com/2006/09/nehru_gandhi_family_tree.jpg?w=540&h=96
Lastly, I need not prove anything to you, my contributions (if any) to society, culture and country are known to those who are matter to me. As the saying goes, those who matter don’t mind, and those who mind don’t matter. I’m sorry, but I don’t think your unauthorized views of me matter enough. Thanks you for the rebuke though.
Viki Cashon says
January 5, 2012 at 2:09 pmI absolutely accept as true with everything you have stated. Actually, I browsed throughout your additional articles and I believe that you are definitely right. Congrats
Abrar says
January 5, 2012 at 6:22 pmPakistan is the best country in the world. You admit India has problems.
Many high scholars, leaders, scientists and successful pakistani businessmen have proven that Pakistan is the most peaceful nation in the world, it is home to the smartest people in the world. Pakistan also has one of the best and largest economies in the world with 0 corruption. This is proven in news and tv here.
farhan khan says
January 7, 2012 at 9:30 am“Samna” and “satyarth prakash” type biased and selective article..
Santosh Kumar A says
January 13, 2012 at 12:17 pmDear Ram,
I wanted to read this in detail, hence today i could find time and completed this.
Well, your article has given me a lot of understanding about the current issues in our nation. I have a little knowledge in politics, history, current affairs and the prevailing issues; and your article made me realize what all kinds of attrocities happened on India.
I never believed in AIT, I always believed that Indians (north and south) were always indians; but as i said I was never goot at History, so never knew details about AIT. Your article gave me lot of information.
I wish we Indians could realize what we have lost till now, and at least now stay united to work towards curing the bruises, and prevent the country from further injuries..
Your writing has a great motivation skill, please keep writing more, and if you wish to – become a professional writer. I am sure your message would reach many.
Regards,
V says
January 15, 2012 at 7:05 pmHey Santosh bhai,
Thanks a lot, I am trying to do the best I can for our culture and religion. I appreciate your feedback. I have yet to read your Gita analysis, will do so as soon as I can 🙂
Thanks again
R.Singh says
January 16, 2012 at 5:14 pmI am sorry to say that this is highly biased and misguiding article. In my personal opinion there is hardly a Hindu in India. Rather there were none from the time immortal. Whom do you call Hindu? If you take out scheduled castes, scheduled tribes and some other who have been deprived social benefits of so called Hinduism, how many Hindus you will be left with? Even Hindu women should be taken out of it, because they have always been considered, either Devi or Dasi,but never an ordinary Insaan. In describing historical facts you have said nothing about those Muslim rulers who ruled over India before Moghuls. They were not less cruel than Moghuls. Jajia Tax, which was abolished by Akbar and reintroduced by Aurangzeb, was introduced before the arrival of Moghuls You has not spoken a word about the period in which India saw its Nadir. I am talking about the period after fall of Guptas’ regime up to advent of Muslim rule. Hindus with their atrocities on their own people were bound to kiss the dust. History has been very cruel to Hindus due to their misdeeds. There is no reprieve even today. Unless you create social equality among Hindus, merely boasting and blaming others is not going to help your cause. There are many other bitter truths about which you have not spoken even a word. Without elaborating I would like to say one thing. First look into the ills,some of which were part of Hinduism from long time and some, which have crept into it with the passing of time and rectify them.
Dr. O. P. Sudrania says
January 17, 2012 at 2:46 pmI recently learnt a beautiful innovative word – inculturation. It has assumed more significance on internet. It is a global network and you do not know, anything about the commentators starting from their name to their cultural identity and intention. Intention is by far the most important. Hence this inculturation is a blasphemous technique, being advanced to pollute the minds by confusing them. I see here a good example.
Ram, a lovely and commedable article. Keep it up. May God bless you!
Jeet Bhargava says
January 17, 2012 at 7:10 pmA Secular Minister Justifying Atrocities on Dalit Women?? Read Here..http://www.dnaindia.com/mumbai/report_minister-justifies-atrocity-on-dalit-widow-in-satara_1637475
V says
January 17, 2012 at 8:33 pmFarhan,
Your comment lacked substantial evidence for the same. Opinions count only when backed with reasoning.
R. Singh ji,
You are mixing up ills that afflict society, with teachings of the Vedas. Using your logic, Islam is a terrorist religion because of the violence in Islamic countries, and Sikhism is a terrorist religion because there are fascist and violent khalistanis, and Atheism is a violent ideology because Stalin and other mass murderers were atheists. Sorry, your rebuke- while appreciated- is still flawed.
There is a difference between teachings of scriptures, and an expression of society. The shruti- Vedas, which we consider eternal teachings of dharma DO NOT hold any such disparities as the ones you made evident.
There is no mention of dalits in the Vedas.
As far as caste discrimination goes, this is also not part of the vedic religion, it found it’s way in society through a flawed cultural mindset.
When Yudhistira is to be crowned yuvaraja, the ministers test him. They produce 4 individuals; a brahmin, kshatriya, vaishya and a shudra. Each of them committed the same crime of killing an innocent person. Yudhistir is asked how he would go about punishing them.
Yudhistira replies: The brahmin should be punished the most, as he is the most learned, if the wise men turn corrupt who will guide our society towards dharma?
The kshatriya should be punished a little lesser, while not as learned as the brahmana, it is his duty to protect his people, not kill the innocent
The vaishya, who is not as erudite as the brahmin, nor has the duty to protect, should be punished somewhat lesser
The shudra, who is least educated should be punished the least, as he went more by instinct and less by erudition.
IF you speak about discrimination against women, please, give a better argument. In ancient days it was the women who CHOSE whom to marry. Swayamvaras were held for both Sita and Draupadi. Before you get into Rama banishing Sita in the forest, that part is mentioned in the Uttara kanda, which is an interpolation of the original text, adn the incident is NOT present in the Valmiki Ramayana.
I hope I have put some of your doubts to rest, needless to say discussion is fruitful only when both sides try to understand each other.
Thank you,
-V
V says
January 17, 2012 at 8:37 pmDr O.P ji,
Namaskaram, thank you for your kind wishes and blessings. Your idea was a beautiful one, may Ishvara give us all the strength, wisdom and means to keep our dharma alive 🙂
@Jeet ji,
That is sad, but again it has nothing to do with the vedic religion. Why do the newspapers conveniently forget to mention incidents of love jihad? Pseudo secularism 😉
Dr. O. P. Sudrania says
January 17, 2012 at 9:17 pmRam, this caste in India is more a business and political recipe than anything else. In USA, the Hindu American Foundation has been misled by their social compulsions, I presume, than any other reasons and have raised their voice by producing a document on Caste. You will be aware of it.
Ramvilas Paswan, Ms Meira Kumar, Babu Jagjivan Ram, Dr Ambedkar are/were all dalits. But are they deprived or they have deprived. I shouldn’t forget my best friend – Mr Chandra Bhan Prasad and his bands who are being misled by some powerful forces mildly termed as anti Hindu brigades. It is all vote bank politics.
I laugh when I see the entire (infamous) Gandhi family with full sized forehead “Tilaks” trying to pose as the biggest Hindus. Yet if you recollect, their entire cast tree is bastardised. Are they Hindus, Muslims or Christians or Parsis, only God knows? But they must facade as Hindus because the vote matters. Power and money go together. You can fill up a book of pages only naming the dalits in high positions. But it is the C*……cs politics which wants to keep the chaos alive to malign Hindus. The other sinister gameplan is to destabilise the subcontinent for geopolitical interests. Ms Sonia Gandhi is playing herself as a pawn in this unfortunate imbecile strategy.
Dr S Radhakrishnan wrote in his Religion and Society treatise, we were all only one caste in the beginning. We were all Brahmins or Sudras. He quotes a Sruti text and states, quote – “A Smrti text says that one is born a Sudra, and through purification he becomes a Brahmin. Dr Radhakrishnan extensively sub quotes as foot notes in this text. I have yet meet a person more learned than Dr Radhakrishnan.
Once I get a free moment, I shall write appropriately on this caste in India. During the British period, it was deliberately promoted by proping up Macaulayiites for divide and rule business. Hence all these apologists are parrots with a rut to keep the rumour industry on. Unfortunate but indubitable at the same time.
Dr. O. P. Sudrania says
January 17, 2012 at 9:17 pmRam, this caste in India is more a business and political recipe than anything else. In USA, the Hindu American Foundation has been misled by their social compulsions, I presume, than any other reasons and have raised their voice by producing a document on Caste. You will be aware of it.
Ramvilas Paswan, Ms Meira Kumar, Babu Jagjivan Ram, Dr Ambedkar are/were all dalits. But are they deprived or they have deprived. I shouldn’t forget my best friend – Mr Chandra Bhan Prasad and his bands who are being misled by some powerful forces mildly termed as anti Hindu brigades. It is all vote bank politics.
I laugh when I see the entire (infamous) Gandhi family with full sized forehead “Tilaks” trying to pose as the biggest Hindus. Yet if you recollect, their entire cast tree is bastardised. Are they Hindus, Muslims or Christians or Parsis, only God knows? But they must facade as Hindus because the vote matters. Power and money go together. You can fill up a book of pages only naming the dalits in high positions. But it is the C*……cs politics which wants to keep the chaos alive to malign Hindus. The other sinister gameplan is to destabilise the subcontinent for geopolitical interests. Ms Sonia Gandhi is playing herself as a pawn in this unfortunate imbecile strategy.
Dr S Radhakrishnan wrote in his Religion and Society treatise, we were all only one caste in the beginning. We were all Brahmins or Sudras. He quotes a Sruti text and states, quote – “A Smrti text says that one is born a Sudra, and through purification he becomes a Brahmin. Dr Radhakrishnan extensively sub quotes as foot notes in this text. I have yet meet a person more learned than Dr Radhakrishnan.
Once I get a free moment, I shall write appropriately on this caste in India. During the British period, it was deliberately promoted by proping up Macaulayiites for divide and rule business. Hence all these apologists are parrots with a rut to keep the rumour industry on. Unfortunate but indubitable at the same time. Osama
Dr. O. P. Sudrania says
January 17, 2012 at 9:42 pmThe DNA article quoted by Jeet brother has been serately sent to me by Google alert. It is nothing to do with secularism, it is the NCP leader who’s boss is the (in)famous Marathha strongman himself was slapped in Delhi. It is again Vote bank politics. Did that slap have a caste? I think we ought to find out. Since last night net is giving lot of problems. When the whole country is ridden with corruption running in billions, this caste card is good to deflect/attract the attention of voters. Muscle, money, and man are working in their best.
The worst case that had happened and medias publicised vociferously was a case of young girl in Gauhati. These incidences are a social curse and infamy to the nation. But the strongman doesn’t care. I feel ashamed whenever I see such incidences anywhere. I think one slap was not enough.
V says
January 19, 2012 at 6:35 amDr. Sudrania ji,
That was some deep insight you have given, I am indebted, thanks for the added knowledge. I concur with all you said
Is there a way I can get in touch with you, perhaps through the editor, to discuss this on a different portal?
Dr. O. P. Sudrania says
January 19, 2012 at 6:18 pmV,
Thanks for your comments, sweet on one aspect if I feel flattered and pinching on its other aspect if I deflect it in the broader national perspectives. These are matters of national shame but the ruler have to realise it. I saw today Kalmadi released on bail of a mere 5 lacs of surety bond who has embazzled money to the tune of 77,000 Crores. At the same time he has been offered his post of presidentship of IOA back. I nearly fainted. If you have to check the advances of this monster of ‘Afzal Khan’ in India, you have to discover a Shivaji. Otherwise they will martyr you like Shyama Prasad or Rajiv Dixit. They are all traitors.
I am in the middle of my difficult post in the Yoga series, which consumes my maximum time. I did contribute some essays on my Australian magazine at the begining of Anna movements, viz. Who Made Anna the Anna, We Still have Gandhi with a difference & etc.
But the second one was started in series, I had to interrupt in the interests of Yoga series which I thought our American freinds need urgently. I suggest your contact through the Editor will be best. With my loving regards,
God bless